Could a Black Hole Split in Two? A Narrow Loophole Appears in New Calculations

A theoretical study in Physical Review D says a black hole spinning near its maximum rate might, in principle, divide in two. No such split has ever been observed.

Could a Black Hole Split in Two? A Narrow Loophole Appears in New Calculations

Black holes merge. Astronomers have watched it happen. Whether one can do the reverse and divide into two smaller black holes is a different question, and a new theoretical paper says physics may not rule it out completely.

The study, “When Black Holes Admit Pair-of-pants Topologies,” appears in Physical Review D. Its authors are Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Manuel Del Piano, Francesco Sannino and Vania Vellucci, according to the University of Southern Denmark release distributed through EurekAlert.

Advertisement

What the researchers asked

The team looked at the physical laws that normally keep a black hole in one piece. They then asked whether any circumstances could let a split happen. Sannino, a co-author who works at the University of Naples Federico II and the Quantum Field Theory Center at the University of Southern Denmark, described the aim in those terms in the university’s statement.

The answer is a qualified one. According to the team’s calculations,

rapidly rotating black holes provide a possible loophole allowing a split to happen.

Advertisement

But a split alone is not enough. The two resulting black holes would also have to move apart instead of falling straight back together.

Sannino said that once this requirement is included, the window largely closes again. The exception, he said, is possibly black holes rotating close to their maximum possible rate.

Why “pair of pants”?

The odd title is geometry. A black hole’s outer boundary is called its horizon. If one horizon divided into two, its path through space and time would look like a pair of trousers: a single upper section that branches into two legs.

Advertisement

Physicists call that shape a pair-of-pants topology. It describes the history of the event, not a picture of anything astronomers could see.

How far the result goes

This is a calculation, not an observation. Indian Defence Review’s summary of the paper notes that no black hole has ever been seen splitting apart. It also says the authors do not establish a physical mechanism that would make an ordinary rotating black hole split.

Another outlet, EGamers, describes the opening as so small that the authors spend much of the paper explaining why it usually stays shut. That fits Sannino’s own account of the window closing again.

Advertisement

Beyond ordinary black holes

The paper also considers more exotic settings. According to the summaries, some higher-dimensional models of gravity contain black-hole-like objects that can become unstable. One example is the black string, an extended object whose horizon can become unstable under particular conditions.

In those models, physicists have already identified objects that can begin to break apart. The authors suggest this hints that the usual rules may behave differently under more exotic conditions. Such models are theoretical, and the sources do not say any of them describe the real universe.

What it means

For now the finding is a statement about what the equations allow. It maps the conditions under which a long-assumed impossibility might not be strictly forbidden. It does not predict that astronomers will find a black hole dividing.

Advertisement

The paper is listed as volume 114, issue 8, of Physical Review D, with the DOI 10.1103/cx69-t466. The research was first publicised in late October. Coverage has continued into early November.

Sources